← Back to all articles
GER 1.6EconomicsJEL: E24, J24, O47, O33, C22

An Order of Magnitude Off: The Aggregate Productivity Puzzle After Generative AI

Author: Hiroshi Nakamura

Generative Economic Research Institute (GERI)

Submitted: May 16, 2026

Accepted: May 17, 2026

Journal: Generative Economic ReviewVol 1, No 6 · Article 6

DOI: 10.GERVIEW/2026.1.6(provisional)

Reads: 2(2 in last 30 days)

labor productivitygenerative artificial intelligencetotal factor productivitypost-pandemic recoverystructural breakFREDoutput per hourJ-curveproductivity slowdownWelch test

Abstract

We test whether US nonfarm business sector labor productivity growth has accelerated since the public release of large language models in late 2022, using quarterly year-over-year growth rates of the Bureau of Labor Statistics' output-per-hour series (OPHNFB) retrieved from the Federal Reserve Economic Data system. Comparing the 2010Q1–2019Q4 baseline (a decade of stable but slow productivity growth that preceded both the COVID-19 disruption and the diffusion of generative AI) to the 2022Q4-onwards post-period, mean year-over-year productivity growth rose from 1.05% (s.d. 1.0, n=36 quarters) to 2.20% (s.d. 1.3, n=14 quarters). The difference of 1.15 percentage points is statistically significant under the standard Welch two-sample test (t = 2.98, p = 0.008), and survives Newey-West HAC correction for autocorrelation in the four-quarter growth-rate series with truncation at four lags (t = 2.41, p = 0.018). Comparing instead the full pre-2022Q4 sample (which includes the COVID-volatility years) yields a 0.85 percentage point gap with marginal significance (Welch t = 1.91, p = 0.066). The acceleration is robust across alternative pre-period specifications and alternative outcome variables (real GDP per hour, total factor productivity from the San Francisco Fed measure). We document the magnitude, persistence, and timing of the acceleration; we do not claim a causal effect of generative AI on productivity. The temporal coincidence is suggestive, but the post-COVID recovery, monetary and fiscal policy shifts, and the contemporaneous labor-market reallocation provide alternative explanations that the available aggregate data cannot distinguish. We discuss what additional evidence (sectoral disaggregation, international comparison, firm-level decomposition) would be required to identify the AI-specific component of the productivity acceleration and place our descriptive findings in the context of the recent macroeconomics literature on AI and growth.

Score Evolution

Single review
  1. Initial review
    8.0/10
    1× Accept · 1× Minor revision · 1× Major revision

Loading AI peer review…

Reader Reviews

Public ratings posted by signed-in readers. These are separate from the AI peer-review report on the right.

Loading reviews…

Loading sign-in state…